Baker Mayfield’s start to the 2026 season has raised questions about the Tampa Bay Buccaneers’ decision to extend him shortly before the season began. The quarterback agreed to a deal worth $55 million per year, but Tampa Bay has opened the season with two losses.
An analysis published by si.com characterized the contract as an overpay based on Mayfield’s early performance. Since 2024, his statistical record includes 27 fumbles, the most among quarterbacks during that span, and 28 interceptions, the second-highest total, according to the report.
Through two games this season, Mayfield has an expected points added mark of negative 21.15, listed as the league’s third-worst figure. He has 398 passing yards, one touchdown, a passer rating of 86.6 and an average of 6.4 yards per attempt.
The report also lists him 28th in passing yards, tied for 28th in touchdown passes, 21st in passer rating and 25th in yards per attempt. He has lost three fumbles and been sacked seven times.
Mayfield’s numbers also include some favorable indicators. He has completed 71% of his passes and thrown one interception through the first two games. The report noted, however, that his ability to make downfield throws has been limited.
Mayfield had said during the offseason contract discussion that he planned to focus on football until the season ended, but the extension was completed just days before the opener. The analysis considered whether the timing could have affected his urgency, while also suggesting that the larger factor may be a change in the offense.
